The study of where our food comes from is rooted in the work of two monumental figures: Alphonse de Candolle and Nikolai Vavilov. While De Candolle laid the historical and botanical foundation, Vavilov revolutionized the field with genetic principles.
1. Alphonse de Candolle (1806–1893)
Known as the "Father of Phytogeography," his 1883 book, Origin of Cultivated Plants, was the first systematic attempt to determine where crops originated.
Key Concepts:
-
Multidisciplinary Evidence: He used four types of evidence to trace plant origins:
- Botanical: Finding where the plant grows wild today.
- Archaeological: Studying seeds or drawings in ancient ruins/tombs.
- Historical: Reviewing ancient writings (e.g., Theophrastus, Pliny).
- Philological (Linguistic): Analyzing common names for plants across different languages.
.
- Restricted Origin: He proposed that crops originated in restricted areas rather than being globally distributed.
- Single Center: He believed each crop had a single, specific region of origin.
- Classification: He studied 247 species and categorized them into classes based on their uses (e.g., roots/bulbs, stems/leaves, fruits, seeds).
2. Nikolai Vavilov (1887–1943)
Vavilov, a Russian geneticist, built upon De Candolle’s work but added a critical genetic dimension.
Key Concepts:
- Centers of Diversity: Vavilov argued that the Center of Origin is the same as the Center of Diversity. If you find a region with the highest genetic variation of a crop, that is likely where it originated.
-
Primary vs. Secondary Centers:
- Primary Center: The original home where the crop was first domesticated from wild ancestors. High frequency of dominant alleles.
- Secondary Center: Regions where the crop developed immense diversity after being introduced from elsewhere (e.g., the diversity of potatoes in Europe).
.
- Law of Homologous Series: He noted that closely related species show similar patterns of variation.
- Mountainous Origins: Vavilov observed that most centers were located in mountainous or hilly regions of tropical and subtropical belts (between 20° and 45° latitude).
Modern Critique:
Today, we know that Vavilov's rule "Center of Diversity = Center of Origin" is not always true. For example, Maize and Tomato have higher genetic diversity in regions far from where they were originally domesticated.
MCQs on de Candolle & Vavilov
1. The book “Origin of Cultivated Plants” was written by:
A. Vavilov
B. Darwin
C. de Candolle
D. Linnaeus
Answer: C. de Candolle
2. de Candolle emphasized the origin of crops based mainly on:
A. Genetic diversity
B. Cytological evidence
C. Historical and botanical evidence
D. Mutation studies
Answer: C. Historical and botanical evidence
3. According to de Candolle, cultivated plants originated in:
A. Random regions
B. Areas of ancient civilization
C. Polar regions
D. Industrial regions
Answer: B. Areas of ancient civilization
4. The main basis of Vavilov’s concept of centres of origin is:
A. Fossil records
B. Maximum genetic diversity
C. Climatic similarity
D. Soil fertility
Answer: B. Maximum genetic diversity
5. Who proposed the concept of Centres of Origin / Centres of Diversity?
A. de Candolle
B. Mendel
C. Vavilov
D. Haeckel
Answer: C. Vavilov
6. The Indian (Indo-Burma) centre of origin is associated with:
A. Wheat and barley
B. Maize and cotton
C. Rice, sugarcane, banana
D. Potato and tomato
Answer: C. Rice, sugarcane, banana
7. Which centre is considered the origin of wheat and barley?
A. Mediterranean
B. Near Eastern
C. Chinese
D. Abyssinian
Answer: B. Near Eastern
8. Coffee originated from which centre according to Vavilov?
A. Indian
B. Central American
C. Mediterranean
D. Abyssinian (Ethiopian)
Answer: D. Abyssinian (Ethiopian)
9. Which crop is correctly matched with its centre of origin?
A. Potato – Indian centre
B. Maize – Central American centre
C. Rice – Mediterranean centre
D. Wheat – South American centre
Answer: B. Maize – Central American centre
10. Vavilov proposed the concept of:
A. Single origin of crops
B. Mutation breeding
C. Centres of diversity
D. Natural selection
Answer: C. Centres of diversity
11. Which is a limitation of de Candolle’s concept?
A. Too many centres
B. Use of genetic evidence
C. Broad and vague regions
D. Overemphasis on diversity
Answer: C. Broad and vague regions
12. Vavilov collected germplasm from approximately:
A. 10 countries
B. 25 countries
C. 64 countries
D. 100 countries
Answer: C. 64 countries
13. The Mediterranean centre is rich in diversity of:
A. Rice and soybean
B. Olive and cabbage
C. Potato and tomato
D. Coffee and sorghum
Answer: B. Olive and cabbage
14. The Chinese centre is known for:
A. Wheat and barley
B. Rice, soybean, tea
C. Maize and cotton
D. Potato and tobacco
Answer: B. Rice, soybean, tea
15. The concept of primary and secondary centres was introduced by:
A. de Candolle
B. Linnaeus
C. Darwin
D. Vavilov
Answer: D. Vavilov
16. Which of the following crops belongs to the South American centre?
A. Sorghum
B. Coffee
C. Potato
D. Rice
Answer: C. Potato
17. The concept of centres of origin is most useful for:
A. Plant taxonomy
B. Plant breeding and germplasm conservation
C. Climate classification
D. Soil management
Answer: B. Plant breeding and germplasm conservation
18. de Candolle’s work was published in:
A. 1753
B. 1826
C. 1882
D. 1926
Answer: C. 1882
19. Which centre shows maximum diversity of maize?
A. South American
B. Near Eastern
C. Central American
D. Mediterranean
Answer: C. Central American
20. Vavilov’s theory is considered superior because it is based on:
A. Ancient literature
B. Linguistic studies
C. Genetic variation
D. Religious texts
Answer: C. Genetic variation
Comments