Biopiracy
1. Definition of Biopiracy
Biopiracy refers to the illegal or unethical appropriation of biological resources, traditional knowledge, or genetic material from indigenous communities or developing countries without proper authorization or compensation.
Often involves patenting or commercial exploitation by corporations or foreign entities.
The term is closely linked to intellectual property rights (IPR) violations.
Key Point: Biopiracy exploits biodiversity and traditional knowledge without recognizing or rewarding the communities who discovered or conserved it.
2. Features of Biopiracy
Unauthorized use – Taking biological resources without permission.
Commercialization – Patenting or selling the product for profit.
Violation of indigenous rights – Exploits local knowledge or traditional practices.
Absence of benefit-sharing – Local communities usually do not get compensation.
Global dimension – Often involves developed countries exploiting resources from developing countries.
3. Examples of Biopiracy
Neem tree (India) – Patented abroad for pesticide use, later revoked after Indian challenge.
Turmeric (India) – Patented in the U.S. for wound-healing properties, challenged successfully.
Basmati rice (India/Pakistan) – Patented by a U.S. company; rights contested.
Hoodia cactus (South Africa) – Used for appetite suppression; patent disputes with San tribes.
Ayurvedic and traditional medicinal plants – Many cases involve patent claims on ancient remedies.
4. Causes of Biopiracy
Weak legal protection for traditional knowledge in developing countries.
Lack of awareness among indigenous communities.
Global patent system loopholes – allows patenting of natural substances or traditional knowledge without prior art recognition.
High commercial value of genetic resources, medicinal plants, and bioactive compounds.
5. Types of Biopiracy
Direct Biopiracy – Taking biological material without consent.
Indirect Biopiracy – Using traditional knowledge or information for commercial purposes without permission.
Patent Biopiracy – Granting patents on naturally occurring substances or traditional practices.
6. Consequences of Biopiracy
Economic Loss – Countries lose revenue from commercialization.
Exploitation of local communities – Their knowledge is used without recognition or compensation.
Loss of biodiversity control – Genetic resources are exploited unsustainably.
Legal conflicts – Patent revocation cases, international disputes.
Ethical concerns – Violation of moral and cultural rights of indigenous people.
7. International Efforts to Combat Biopiracy
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD), 1992
Recognizes the rights of countries over their genetic resources.
Promotes access and benefit-sharing with local communities.
Nagoya Protocol, 2010
Provides a legal framework for fair and equitable sharing of benefits from genetic resources.
World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO)
Works to protect traditional knowledge and prevent wrongful patents.
TRIPS Agreement (WTO)
Sets minimum standards for IP protection; includes provisions for protecting traditional knowledge indirectly.
8. Measures Against Biopiracy
Documentation of Traditional Knowledge
Example: India’s Traditional Knowledge Digital Library (TKDL) contains info on medicinal plants and practices to prevent wrongful patents.
National Biodiversity Acts
Example: India’s Biodiversity Act, 2002 regulates access to biological resources.
Prior Informed Consent (PIC)
Requires companies or researchers to obtain consent from indigenous communities before using resources.
Benefit-Sharing Agreements
Ensures communities receive royalties, technology transfer, or profit-sharing.
9. Examples of Preventive Actions
Neem patent revoked (2000) – U.S. patent on neem-based pesticide revoked after Indian challenge.
Turmeric patent revoked (1997) – U.S. patent on turmeric for wound healing revoked.
Hoodia cactus benefit-sharing – San tribes compensated after legal agreements.
10. Importance of Combating Biopiracy
Protects sovereignty over genetic resources.
Encourages sustainable use of biodiversity.
Recognizes and rewards traditional knowledge holders.
Reduces unethical commercialization by corporations.
11. Key Terms
Traditional Knowledge (TK) – Knowledge developed over generations by indigenous communities.
Genetic Resources – Material from plants, animals, or microbes with actual or potential value.
Prior Informed Consent (PIC) – Approval required from local communities before accessing resources.
Benefit-Sharing – Sharing profits, technology, or other benefits with communities providing the resources.
50 MCQs on Biopiracy with Answers
Biopiracy is primarily concerned with:
a) Stealing computer software
b) Unauthorized use of biological resources and traditional knowledge
c) Industrial espionage
d) Trademark violations
Answer: b) Unauthorized use of biological resources and traditional knowledge
Which of the following is an example of biopiracy?
a) Patenting a new drug derived from turmeric without acknowledging traditional knowledge
b) Publishing research on plants in a journal
c) Selling common food items in a market
d) Trademarking a logo
Answer: a) Patenting a new drug derived from turmeric without acknowledging traditional knowledge
The term “biopiracy” was first coined by:
a) Vandana Shiva
b) Gregor Mendel
c) Rachel Carson
d) Norman Borlaug
Answer: a) Vandana Shiva
Which of the following is a feature of biopiracy?
a) Voluntary sharing of resources
b) Unauthorized commercialization of genetic resources
c) Public dissemination of knowledge
d) Free benefit-sharing
Answer: b) Unauthorized commercialization of genetic resources
Neem tree patent in the U.S. was eventually:
a) Granted permanently
b) Revoked after challenge
c) Sold to India
d) Ignored by Indian government
Answer: b) Revoked after challenge
Turmeric patent in the U.S. was revoked because:
a) The invention was not useful
b) Prior art existed in traditional knowledge
c) Turmeric was genetically modified
d) Patent fees were not paid
Answer: b) Prior art existed in traditional knowledge
Biopiracy often affects which communities most?
a) Urban populations
b) Indigenous communities
c) International corporations
d) Government officials
Answer: b) Indigenous communities
Which of the following is a cause of biopiracy?
a) Strong legal protection of traditional knowledge
b) Weak legal systems in developing countries
c) Public awareness
d) Ethical commercialization
Answer: b) Weak legal systems in developing countries
Hoodia cactus patent issues involved which community?
a) Maasai
b) San tribes of South Africa
c) Aboriginal Australians
d) Native Americans
Answer: b) San tribes of South Africa
Basmati rice patent controversy involved:
a) India and Pakistan
b) U.S. company
c) Both a & b
d) Only India
Answer: c) Both a & b
Which of the following is NOT a type of biopiracy?
a) Direct biopiracy
b) Indirect biopiracy
c) Patent biopiracy
d) Trademark piracy
Answer: d) Trademark piracy
Direct biopiracy refers to:
a) Using resources without permission
b) Using software illegally
c) Registering a trademark
d) Industrial espionage
Answer: a) Using resources without permission
Indirect biopiracy refers to:
a) Selling stolen equipment
b) Using traditional knowledge for profit without consent
c) Copying books
d) Patenting machinery
Answer: b) Using traditional knowledge for profit without consent
Patent biopiracy involves:
a) Selling patented machinery
b) Granting patents on naturally occurring substances or traditional knowledge
c) Filing trademarks
d) Publishing articles
Answer: b) Granting patents on naturally occurring substances or traditional knowledge
One consequence of biopiracy is:
a) Economic loss for developing countries
b) Increased public awareness
c) Strengthened biodiversity control
d) Ethical commercialization
Answer: a) Economic loss for developing countries
Which international agreement recognizes the rights of countries over their genetic resources?
a) TRIPS
b) CBD (Convention on Biological Diversity)
c) Nagoya Protocol
d) Paris Convention
Answer: b) CBD (Convention on Biological Diversity)
Nagoya Protocol (2010) focuses on:
a) IP protection for software
b) Access and benefit-sharing from genetic resources
c) Trademark regulation
d) Patent fees
Answer: b) Access and benefit-sharing from genetic resources
WIPO works to:
a) Promote traditional knowledge protection and prevent wrongful patents
b) Regulate global trade
c) Sell biological resources
d) Fund indigenous communities
Answer: a) Promote traditional knowledge protection and prevent wrongful patents
TRIPS agreement is related to:
a) Minimum global standards for IP protection
b) Global trade in goods
c) Environmental protection
d) Biodiversity conservation
Answer: a) Minimum global standards for IP protection
TKDL stands for:
a) Traditional Knowledge Digital Library
b) Tribal Knowledge Documentation List
c) Technology Knowledge Development Lab
d) Traditional Knowledge Documentation Law
Answer: a) Traditional Knowledge Digital Library
One preventive measure against biopiracy is:
a) Strong patenting of all plants
b) Documentation of traditional knowledge
c) Ignoring indigenous knowledge
d) Selling resources abroad freely
Answer: b) Documentation of traditional knowledge
Which Indian law regulates access to biological resources?
a) Biodiversity Act, 2002
b) Patent Act, 1970
c) TRIPS Act
d) Environment Protection Act
Answer: a) Biodiversity Act, 2002
Prior Informed Consent (PIC) means:
a) Getting permission from indigenous communities before using resources
b) Filing a patent
c) Marketing a product internationally
d) Sharing profits with government only
Answer: a) Getting permission from indigenous communities before using resources
Benefit-sharing ensures:
a) Communities get recognition, royalties, or technology transfer
b) Companies take all profits
c) Resources are taken freely
d) Patents are not challenged
Answer: a) Communities get recognition, royalties, or technology transfer
Biopiracy primarily involves exploitation of:
a) Minerals
b) Fossils
c) Biological resources and genetic material
d) Machines
Answer: c) Biological resources and genetic material
Which of the following was a famous example of biopiracy challenge?
a) Revocation of U.S. patent on neem
b) Patenting of aspirin
c) Trademark of Coca-Cola
d) Registration of Microsoft Windows
Answer: a) Revocation of U.S. patent on neem
Which is a major ethical concern in biopiracy?
a) Violation of cultural and moral rights of indigenous communities
b) Global trade issues
c) High patent fees
d) Commercial branding
Answer: a) Violation of cultural and moral rights of indigenous communities
Biopiracy usually occurs in:
a) Developed countries exploiting developing countries
b) Rural communities exploiting cities
c) Urban populations exploiting each other
d) None of the above
Answer: a) Developed countries exploiting developing countries
Traditional knowledge refers to:
a) Modern scientific discoveries
b) Knowledge developed by indigenous communities over generations
c) Patented inventions
d) Commercial products only
Answer: b) Knowledge developed by indigenous communities over generations
Which is an example of genetic resource used in biopiracy?
a) Plant DNA
b) Bacterial strains
c) Medicinal plants
d) All of the above
Answer: d) All of the above
Why is biopiracy a problem for developing countries?
a) They lose control over their resources
b) Economic exploitation occurs
c) Indigenous communities are not compensated
d) All of the above
Answer: d) All of the above
Which of the following prevents wrongful patenting using traditional knowledge?
a) TKDL
b) TRIPS
c) WIPO
d) CBD
Answer: a) TKDL
CBD encourages:
a) Sustainable use of biodiversity
b) Free commercial exploitation
c) Biopiracy
d) Ignoring indigenous knowledge
Answer: a) Sustainable use of biodiversity
Who is mainly responsible for preventing biopiracy?
a) Governments and regulatory bodies
b) Corporations
c) Consumers
d) Journalists
Answer: a) Governments and regulatory bodies
One measure to combat biopiracy internationally is:
a) Strengthening national laws
b) International agreements like CBD and Nagoya Protocol
c) Documenting traditional knowledge
d) All of the above
Answer: d) All of the above
An example of benefit-sharing agreement is:
a) Hoodia cactus case
b) Neem patent challenge
c) Turmeric patent challenge
d) All of the above
Answer: a) Hoodia cactus case
Biopiracy can lead to:
a) Loss of biodiversity control
b) Economic inequality
c) Exploitation of knowledge
d) All of the above
Answer: d) All of the above
Which country’s traditional knowledge is documented in TKDL?
a) India
b) Brazil
c) South Africa
d) USA
Answer: a) India
The main goal of the Nagoya Protocol is:
a) Promote patents on all plants
b) Ensure fair and equitable sharing of benefits from genetic resources
c) Grant global patent rights
d) Ignore indigenous rights
Answer: b) Ensure fair and equitable sharing of benefits from genetic resources
Biopiracy is often linked with:
a) Intellectual property rights violations
b) Environmental pollution
c) Trademark disputes
d) Currency manipulation
Answer: a) Intellectual property rights violations
Which of the following is a preventive step against biopiracy?
a) Documentation and patent opposition
b) Ignoring traditional knowledge
c) Allowing unrestricted use
d) Commercial secrecy
Answer: a) Documentation and patent opposition
Who benefits in biopiracy if unchecked?
a) Indigenous communities
b) Corporations or foreign entities
c) Local farmers
d) Government
Answer: b) Corporations or foreign entities
Which of the following was challenged for basmati rice patent?
a) U.S. company RiceTec
b) Indian government
c) TRIPS organization
d) WIPO
Answer: a) U.S. company RiceTec
A characteristic of indirect biopiracy is:
a) Using genetic resources without consent
b) Using traditional knowledge for patenting or profit without acknowledgment
c) Physical theft of plants
d) Publishing scientific articles
Answer: b) Using traditional knowledge for patenting or profit without acknowledgment
Which of the following is part of combating biopiracy legally?
a) Strengthening patent laws
b) Prior informed consent (PIC)
c) Benefit-sharing agreements
d) All of the above
Answer: d) All of the above
Biopiracy is considered unethical because:
a) It violates IP rights
b) It exploits communities for profit
c) It ignores traditional knowledge
d) All of the above
Answer: d) All of the above
Which body helps developing countries protect traditional knowledge internationally?
a) WIPO
b) WTO
c) IMF
d) CBD
Answer: a) WIPO
Biopiracy often involves which sector?
a) Pharmaceutical and biotech industries
b) Automotive industries
c) Textile industries
d) Construction
Answer: a) Pharmaceutical and biotech industries
Documentation of traditional knowledge helps in:
a) Preventing wrongful patenting
b) Preserving indigenous knowledge
c) Legal evidence in disputes
d) All of the above
Answer: d) All of the above
Which of the following is an important principle in combating biopiracy?
a) Prior informed consent
b) Benefit-sharing
c) Documentation of knowledge
d) All of the above
Answer: d) All of the above
Comments